yen-yen and five other budget apps, side by side
If you want your bank and card transactions to appear on their own, pick an app with bank sync: yen-yen has none. If you would rather never re-link an account, and want a quick entry, four kakeibo buckets and company money kept apart, yen-yen fits.
Prices and limits checked on 2026-11-20 on each company’s own pages, listed under Sources. “Not listed” means we did not find the feature on those pages, not that the app lacks it.
The comparison
| What you get | yen-yen | Money Forward ME | Zaim | Moneytree | YNAB | Monarch |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bank linking | None. You type, scan receipts, open statement files and forward card alert emails from supported card companies. | Automatic. Links banks, cards and other services.[1] | Automatic. Bank and card linking on Free and Premium.[2] | Automatic. Up to 50 financial services.[3][4] | Select countries. Direct Import supports select US, Canadian, UK and EU banks; no institutions elsewhere, so none in Japan.[5][6] | Automatic. Connected accounts sync.[7] |
| Keeping the link working | Nothing to re-link. There is no connection to break. | Some services down. 55 services listed as not linking as of 2026-11-19 17:50, no automatic or manual update (mostly point cards and stores; 9 affect only some users).[8] | Pauses on Free. Fetching stops after 90 days without a login. Banks that need a one-time password are not updated on a schedule.[2][9] | Re-authorize periodically. Banks linked by API have an expiry and need re-authorizing from time to time.[10] | Not listed. | Re-authorize sometimes. Connections that need MFA: "You may need to reauthorize your connection every 30–90 days."[11][7] |
| Free plan: accounts | 3 active accounts. Pro and Family have no cap. | 4 linked services.[1] | No limit. On Free and Premium alike.[12] | 50 services.[3] | No free plan. 34-day trial.[5] | No free plan. 7-day trial.[13][14] |
| Free plan: history | No cut-off. | Past 1 year.[1] | No storage limit. Downloads cover 2 years either side on Free; the balance graph shows 1 month.[15][2] | No cut-off stated. Entries from the day you register are kept for good.[3] | No free plan. | No free plan. |
| Price | Pro ¥600/month or ¥6,000/year. Family ¥1,200/month or ¥12,000/year. 7 days free. | Standard ¥540/month on the web, ¥590 through the app stores. Advanced ¥980.[1] | Premium ¥440/month or ¥4,378/year on the web; ¥480 or ¥4,800 through the app.[2] | Grow ¥390/month or ¥3,900/year on the web; ¥430 or ¥4,300 through the app.[4] | $14.99/month or $109/year, plus tax.[5] | Core $99.99/year, Plus $199.99/year.[14] |
| PayPay | CSV import on iPhone and Android. | CSV import on iPhone and Android, up to 100 rows per file.[16][1] | No link yet. Zaim suggests a manual account and its e-money data import.[17] | Not supported. QR payment apps such as PayPay have no announced date.[18] | Not listed. | Not listed. |
| Kakeibo buckets | Built in. Needs, wants, culture, unexpected. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Not listed. |
| Company money and claims | Free. Mark company-paid spending; it leaves household totals and the Company view shows what is still owed. Receipt ZIP export is Pro. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Work plan, ¥500/month. AI expense detection and expense reports.[19][4] | Not listed. | Plus plan. Business tracking beside personal finances.[20] |
Scroll the table sideways.
Where they are better
- Automatic bank and card sync. Money Forward ME, Zaim, Moneytree and Monarch pull transactions in for you, and YNAB does in the countries it supports.[1][2][3][5] yen-yen does not; you type, scan or import.
- Investments and assets. Money Forward ME’s Advanced course builds a portfolio and forecasts dividends.[1] yen-yen tracks cash, bank, card, loan and wallet balances, not holdings.
- Business paperwork. Moneytree’s Work plan writes expense reports, and Monarch Plus has business tracking.[19][20] yen-yen keeps company money apart and exports a monthly receipt ZIP, but it is not a set of company books.
- A longer free try. YNAB gives 34 days before you pay.[5] yen-yen’s paid plans give 7, though the solo ledger is free for good.
Where yen-yen is better
- Nothing to re-link, ever. No bank login means no connection to break, no fetch that pauses when you stop opening the app, and no bank password to type again.
- A free plan that shows all your history. No cut-off on how far back you can look; Money Forward ME’s free plan shows the past year.[1] Free holds 3 active accounts.
- A quick entry. An amount alone is a whole entry; the shop and the bucket can wait.
- 4 buckets, not 40 categories. Every spend is a need, a want, culture or the unexpected. How kakeibo works.
- Company money kept apart, on Free. Mark what you paid for your company and the Company view shows what is still owed to you.
Questions people ask
- Does yen-yen sync with my bank automatically?
- No. yen-yen never logs in to a bank. Entries come from what you type, receipts you scan, statement files you open (PDF, CSV or Excel, PayPay CSV included) and card alert emails you forward from supported card companies. If you want transactions to appear with no effort at all, an app with bank sync will suit you better.
- How much can I do on the free plan?
- The solo ledger is free, with no cut-off on how far back your history goes. Free holds up to 3 active accounts and includes 30 AI receipt reads a month. Pro adds any number of accounts, AI statement import, Ask and tax exports.
- Can I move my data in from another app?
- Yes, if that app exports CSV. yen-yen imports CSV files, including PayPay CSV, and reads bank and card statements as PDF, CSV, TSV, TXT or Excel. You approve every row before it is saved.
- Why compare with apps that do something different?
- Because people choosing a budget app weigh the same things: how entries get in, what the free plan holds and what it costs. We list what each app says on its own pages, with links, so you can check every cell.
Sources
Each page was read on 2026-11-20. yen-yen’s own facts come from the app and its pricing page. Product names belong to their owners; yen-yen is not affiliated with any of them. Spot something out of date? Email kensaurus@gmail.com.
- Money Forward ME: コース一覧|マネーフォワード ME (2026-11-20)
- Zaim: プレミアム会員のご紹介|家計簿アプリ くふう Zaim (2026-11-20)
- Moneytree: Moneytree 資産管理をもっと自由に|マネーツリー (2026-11-20)
- Moneytree: プランと料金|マネーツリー (2026-11-20)
- YNAB: Pricing | YNAB (2026-11-20)
- YNAB: My bank isn’t listed in YNAB (2026-11-20)
- Monarch: Guide to Connecting Your Accounts (Monarch Help) (2026-11-20)
- Money Forward ME: システム対応中で口座連携が正常に行えていない金融関連サービスの一覧(2026年11月19日 17時50分 現在) (2026-11-20)
- Zaim: 連携設定の使い方(Zaim ご利用ガイド) (2026-11-20)
- Moneytree: 金融機関のAPI再認証について(ヘルプセンター、2024年8月20日) (2026-11-20)
- Monarch: Connection Status Messaging (Monarch Help) (2026-11-20)
- Zaim: 銀行・カードの登録数に上限はありますか(Zaim よくある質問) (2026-11-20)
- Monarch: Pricing (Monarch Help) (2026-11-20)
- Monarch: Monarch Pricing: Personal Finance App Plans (2026-11-20)
- Zaim: 履歴の保存制限はありますか(Zaim よくある質問) (2026-11-20)
- Money Forward ME: PayPayの取引履歴CSVファイルの読み込み機能について (2026-11-20)
- Zaim: PayPay と連携できますか(Zaim よくある質問) (2026-11-20)
- Moneytree: PayPayや楽天ペイなどに対応していますか(ヘルプセンター、2026年1月22日) (2026-11-20)
- Moneytree: Moneytree Work & Corporate 経費管理をスマートに|マネーツリー (2026-11-20)
- Monarch: Business Tracking (Monarch Help) (2026-11-20)
Snap tonight's receipt.
Try it without an account and your phone reads the receipt on its own. Sign in and allow AI for the AI read, usually about 5 seconds, 30 a month on the free ledger. Pro reads 300 a month and adds Ask and statement import; Family shares it all with your household. If it isn't for you, walk off with no email left behind.
